Ep 21 - The Mixing Debate: Science vs. Feel—Which One Actually Wins?

Do You Really Need Audio Theory to Mix Great?

Some of us love the graphs. Some of us love the vibe. In this episode, we (Chris & Steve) talk about the sweet spot between technical knowledge and practical decision-making.

How much theory do you actually need? When does ear training beat book learning? And how do you keep your mixes translating on cars, phones, earbuds, and studio monitors without chasing your tail?

We also answer a listener question about mixes that sound muddy or tinny on different systems, and lay out a quick, repeatable translation check using references you already love.

Special thanks to our sponsor, Audient.

We’ve been leaning on the iD-series interfaces lately: clean when you want it, pushable when you need it.

You’ll Learn:

• The real value of technical knowledge, and where it stops helping

• Ear training that actually speeds up your mix decisions

• A 10-minute translation test you can repeat every mix

• How to use references on each system before judging your own mix

• Why “enjoy the journey” is more than a motivational poster in the studio

Topics & Stories:

• Andrew Scheps vs. “feel-first” mixers - two valid paths to great results

• Harman curves, compression “definitions,” and the limits of theory

• Plugin Doctor curiosity vs. productivity

• The car test (done right): know the system before you judge the mix

• Gearspace nostalgia and why we avoid unproductive debates

Listener Q&A:
“My mixes don’t translate. They’re muddy on one system and thin on another.”
Our take: start with references on each system, then compare yours. Know your playback rigs (car, living room, headphones) by listening to pro mixes first, then A/B to gauge if you’re truly off, or just unfamiliar with the system.

Final Takeaway:
Learn enough to move faster, train your ears relentlessly, and keep asking, “Does this serve the song?” Translation comes from knowing your systems and using references, not buying a new pair of speakers.

👉 Got a question for us?
📩 Submit it here: Form Link
We’ll answer as many as we can in upcoming shows.